Introduced at the 1981 National Order of the Arrow Conference, the Founder's Award was created to honor and recognize those Arrowmen who have given outstanding service to the lodge. The award is reserved for an Arrowmen who demonstrates to fellow Arrowmen that he or she memorializes in his or her everyday life the spirit of achievement as described by founder E. Urner Goodman and cofounder Carroll A. Edson.

The Award is a handsome bronze medallion bearing the likenesses of E. Urner Goodman and cofounder Carroll A. Edson. Also available is a special Founder's Award arrow ribbon, with a gold colored arrow suspended from a red ribbon.

Lodges may petition the national Order of the Arrow Committee to present up to four awards annually, based on lodge membership. If the lodge presents more than one award, one must be to a youth under the age of 21. Nominations must be made on form No. 24-137.

The following is list of the Hunnikick Lodge 76 Arrowmen who have been awarded the Founder's Award:
James L. Moore , Jr. December 28, 1983
James W. Entwistle December 27, 1984
Stephen Chappell January 4, 1991
Marc H. Circus January 4, 1991
Charles H. Roberts, Jr. January 4, 1992
Craig S. Bedard January 14, 1992
Chris Gehringer January 8, 1993
Edward J. Ryder. Jr. January 8, 1993
William H. Chappell December 1, 1994
Anthony J. Vitullo. Jr. December 1, 1994
Satish K. Moorthy January 8, 1995
Gene K. Skow January 8, 1995
Erik A. Dill January 7, 1996
Satya N. Moorthy January 7, 1996
Brian Busch January 5, 1997
Christopher English January 11, 1998
Steven Stratton January 11, 1998
Ryan J. Bell January 3, 1999
Richard P. Smithson January 3, 1999
Chuck E. DelCamp January 2, 2000
Samuel J. Rowand January 2, 2000
Eric L. Stinson January 7, 2001
Sally Eldridge January 7, 2001
J. Kevin O'Connell January 6, 2002
Ronald Y. Dresslove January 5, 2003
William Rupp January 4, 2004
Brad Henricksen January 9, 2005
Michael Whitby January 9, 2005
Charles Fajgier January 8, 2006
H. Charles Riley, Jr. January 7, 2007
Michael T Youngkin January 7, 2007
Nicholas T Nowak January 4, 2009
J. Ryan Zambon January 4, 2009